PJM Coronavirus (COVID-19) Information, maintenance planned

Committees & Groups

Issue Details

Effective Load Carrying Capability for Limited Duration Resources and Intermittent Resources

PJM staff is bringing this issue forward for consideration based on two sources: 1) The Planning Committee has been discussing switching to an Effective Load Carrying Capability (ELCC) method to calculate the capability of wind and solar units in the capacity market. 2) In response to a paper hearing FERC initiated in Docket No. EL19-100 regarding the capability of energy storage resources, stakeholders have proposed, and PJM supports, switching to an ELCC method to calculate the capability of energy storage resources.

Issue Details

Issue Status: Awaiting Senior Committee Approval
Stakeholder Body: Capacity Capability Senior Task Force
Stakeholder Process Status: Consensus
Issue Catalyst: PJM and FERC Docket No. EL19-100
Date Created: 3.26.2020
MC Approval Date:
Target Completion Date: 1.29.2021
Actual Completion Date:
FERC Filing(s): Yes
Agreement Change(s):
Manual Change(s): No
MC Annual Plan: 2020
Date Documents
6.22.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
Draft Minutes - CCSTF - 6.4.2020  PDF
Item 4 - Terminology for ICAP, UCAP, CIRs & ELCC  PDF
Item 6 - Draft Poll on Solutions Options for Select CCSTF  PDF
Item 7A - PJM’s Initial ELCC Solution Package  PDF
Item 7B - Forward Electric Load Carrying Capability - AEP Energy  PDF
Item 8 - Manual vs Tariff Tracker  XLS
Item 9 - Resource Adequacy Paper Scope  PDF
Options & Packages Matrix  XLS
Options & Packages Matrix - Post Meeting  XLS
ELCC Numerical Example  XLS
7.8.2020 Meeting materials from the MIC meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
Item 7 - Update on Capacity Capability Senior Task Force  PDF
8.12.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - CCSTF - 8.7.2020  PDF
Item 2 - Capacity Value of Storage Resources  PDF
Item 3 - Comparison of Latest Storage Simulated Dispatch Method  PDF
Item 4 - Second Draft Preliminary ELCC Results  PDF
Item 5A - Miscellaneous Solution Details  PDF
Item 5B - PJM Proposal for Using E3 Delta Method  PDF
Item 6A - ELCC MMU Package & Follow Up Discussion  PDF
Item 6B - Joint Stakeholder Package  PDF
Item 6C - AEP Fixed or Float 10 Delivery Year Package Summary  PDF
Options & Packages Matrix  XLS
Options & Packages Matrix - Post Meeting  XLS
Options & Packages Matrix - Post Meeting - Package A Corrected 8.17.2020  XLS
8.6.2020 Meeting materials from the OC meeting
Item 1B - Draft Minutes - OC - 7.9.2020  PDF
10.14.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - CCSTF - 10.8.2020  PDF
Item 2A - RAA Language - Redline - October 6th vs. October 13th  PDF
Item 2B - Conforming Tariff Changes  PDF
9.2.2020 Meeting materials from the MIC meeting
Agenda  PDF
10.7.2020 Meeting materials from the MIC meeting
Draft Minutes - MIC - 9.2.2020  PDF
Item 14A - ELCC Data Submittal Requirements  PDF
Item 14B - ELCC Data Submission Requirements & Deadlines  PDF
9.1.2020 Meeting materials from the PC meeting
Agenda  PDF
Item 16 - Effective Load Carrying Capability Data Submission Requirements & Deadlines for Manual 21  PDF
4.27.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - CCSTF - 4.7.2020  PDF
Item 2 - Storage Issue Swimlane  PDF
Item 3 - Scope of Limited Duration Resource  PDF
Item 4 - Update on FERC Paper Hearing on Capability Rules  PDF
Item 5 - ELCC at other ISORTOs  PDF
Item 5A - Proposed Changes to Issue Charge  PDF
Item 5B - Work Plan  PDF
Item 6 - Reserve Requirement Study & Effective Load Carrying Capability  PDF
Item 7 - Proposed ELCC Design Components with Examples of Solution Options  PDF
Action Item Responses - 4.7.2020  PDF
Options & Packages Matrix  XLS
7.7.2020 Meeting materials from the PC meeting
Agenda  PDF
9.11.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
10.6.2020 Meeting materials from the PC meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
Item 3 - Draft Minutes - PC - 9.1.2020  PDF
Item 12A - ELCC Data Submittal Requirements  PDF
Item 12B - ELCC Data Submission Requirements & Deadlines  PDF
7.9.2020 Meeting materials from the OC meeting
Agenda  PDF
Item 8 - Capacity Capability Senior Task Force Update  PDF
7.16.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Draft Minutes - CCSTF - 7.10.2020  PDF
Item 2A - First Draft Assumptions of PJM First Draft Assumptions of PJM Effective Load Carrying Capability Model (ELCC) Model  PDF
Item 2B - First Draft Methodology Appendix of PJM ELCC Model  PDF
Item 2 - First Draft Methodology Highlights of PJM ELCC Model  PDF
Item 3 - Dispatch Effects on ELCC  PDF
Item 4 - Resource Adequacy Paper Scope  PDF
Item 5 - Terms Updated for Workshop - 6.25.2020  PDF
Item 6 - Package Poll  PDF
Item 7B - Additional Details on Transition Plan  PDF
6.25.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF Workshop meeting
Agenda  PDF
Item 3 - Terminology for Installed Capacity (ICAP), Unforced Capacity (UCAP), Capacity Interconnection Rights (CIRs) & Electric Load Carrying Capability (ELCC) - Definitions & Functions  PDF
Item 4 - Effective Load Carrying Capability Technical Considerations  PDF
Item 5A - PJM Initial Proposal Package for ELCC Solution  PDF
Item 5B - Forward Electric Load Carrying Capability - AEP Energy  PDF
Item 5C - ELCC Numerical Example  XLS
6.4.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
Draft Minutes - CCSTF - 5.20.2020  PDF
Item 2 - Finalized Work Plan  PDF
Options & Packages Matrix  XLS
8.31.2020 Meeting materials from the MRC Special Session - Capacity Capability Senior Task Force First Read meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
Item 1 - CCSTF Voting Results - Presentation  PDF
Item 1 - CCSTF Background Overview - Informational Only  PDF
Item 2A - Main Motion - Solution Package A - Presentation  PDF
Item 2B - Alternative Solution Package D - Presentation  PDF
Item 2C - RAA Draft Revision for Effective Load Carrying Capability  PDF
Item 3B - ELCC Submission Requirements and Deadlines for Manual 21  PDF
CCSTF Matrix - Post Meeting  XLS
7.10.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
Item 4 - Manual versus Tariff Tracker  XLS
Item 6-7 - PJM ELCC Model: First Draft Methodology Highlights  PDF
Item 7A - PJM ELCC Model: First Draft Assumptions  PDF
Item 7B - PJM ELCC Model: First Draft Methodology Appendix  PDF
Item 8 - Resource Adequacy Paper Scope  PDF
Item 9 - Terms Updates for June 25 Workshop  PDF
Draft Minutes - CCSTF - 6.22.2020  PDF
Item 2 - Work Plan  PDF
Item 5 - First Draft Prelim Electric Load Carrying Capability Results  PDF
Item 6A - Dispatch Hourly Results  PDF
Item 6A - Dispatch Hourly Results Data  XLS
Item 6B - ELCC Dispatch Adjustment Factor  PDF
Item 6C - Capacity Value of Storage Resources  PDF
Item 10 - Poll Results  PDF
Options & Packages Matrix  XLS
Options & Packages Matrix - Post Meeting  XLS
1.8.2020 Meeting materials from the MIC meeting
Agenda  DOC
5.20.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
Draft Minutes - CCSTF - 4.27.2020  PDF
Item 2 - Capability Rules Procedural Swimlane  PDF
Item 3 - Updated Work Plan  PDF
Item 5A - Effective Load Carrying Capability Classes  PDF
Item 5B - Effective Load Carrying Capability Timing Considerations  PDF
Item 6A - Unit Performance Adjustment for Intermittent Resources & Limited Duration  PDF
Options Matrix - Consolidated Post Meeting  XLS
Options & Packages Matrix  XLS
Options & Packages Matrix - Post Meeting  XLS
4.14.2020 Meeting materials from the PC meeting
Agenda  PDF
Item 3 - Draft Minutes - PC - 3.10.2020  PDF
8.17.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
8.5.2020 Meeting materials from the MIC meeting
Draft Minutes - MIC - 7.8.2020  PDF
8.20.2020 Meeting materials from the MRC meeting
Agenda  PDF
Item 7 - CCSTF Update - Presentation  PDF
Item 7 - CCSTF Voting Results  PDF
8.7.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
Draft Minutes - CCSTF - 7.27.2020  PDF
Item 2 - Work Plan  PDF
Item 3A - Performance Adjustment Hours  PDF
Item 3A - Performance Adjustment Hours - Data  XLS
Item 3 - Capacity Market Impacts  PDF
Item 4C - E3 Allocating Effective Load Carrying Capability (ELCC) MW from Portfolio to Classes  PDF
Item 5A - Approaches to ELCC Modeling  PDF
Item 5B - Proposed Revision to Simulated Dispatch of Storage in ELCC Model  PDF
Item 5C - Additional Details for Hydro with Non-Pumped Storage  PDF
Item 5C - Miscellaneous Solution Options   PDF
Item 6A - Fixed or Float 10 Delivery Years  PDF
Item 6B - Joint ELCC Stakeholder Presentation  PDF
Item 6C - IMM Package  PDF
Item 8 - Poll Results Reevaluated  PDF
Options & Packages Matrix  XLS
Wind Solar Shapes  XLS
10.8.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
Item 3 - RAA Language  PDF
9.17.2020 Meeting materials from the MRC meeting
Agenda  PDF
Consent Agenda A - Draft Minutes - MRC - 8.20.2020  PDF
Item 4 - CCSTF - Presentation  PDF
Item 4 - CCSTF Matrix - Post Meeting - 8.17.2020  XLS
Item 4 - Main Motion Solution Package A - Presentation  PDF
Item 4 - Alternate Motion Amendment to Joint Stakeholder Package  PDF
Item 4 - CCSTF - Joint Stakeholders Package - Presentation  PDF
Item 4 - ELCC MMU - Presentation  PDF
Item 4 - Draft RAA Revisions - Redline  PDF
Item 4 - Draft RAA Revisions - Clean  PDF
7.27.2020 Meeting materials from the CCSTF meeting
Agenda  PDF
Agenda  DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - CCSTF - 7.16.2020  PDF
Item 2 - Voting Application: Overview for Voting  PDF
Item 4 - Hydro with Storage ELCC Preliminary Results  PDF
Item 5 - Poll Results  PDF
Item 6 - Emerging Strawman  PDF
Options & Packages Matrix  XLS
Options & Packages Matrix - Post Meeting  XLS
Date Type Documents
There are no governing documents currently associated with this issue